MLB Rumors: Surprising New Pete Alonso Suitor Emerges From AL East

New York Mets first baseman Pete Alonso reacts during 2025 game.

Pete Alonso remains a top New York Mets priority after a 38-homer, 126-RBI season, and early chatter says recent talks between his camp and New York “went well.”

Why Baltimore Could Be a Real Threat

Still, industry buzz and a Jon Heyman link now includes a genuine dark-horse: the Baltimore Orioles.

The fit is obvious. Baltimore wants a thump-first middle-order bat for 2026 and has the flexibility to slot Alonso at DH or first while continuing to contend with its young core.

.@JonHeyman reports that the Orioles could be in the mix to sign Pete Alonso 👀 pic.twitter.com/CsUZy4ldh2
— New York Post Sports (@nypostsports) November 13, 2025

Multiple outlets have framed Baltimore as a serious possibility if the bidding stretches beyond short-term money, and the club’s leadership has publicly indicated a willingness to invest to win now.

Where the Mets Stand After a “Good” Meeting

New York knows replacing Alonso’s production and presence would be brutal. The front office is motivated to keep him and has reason to feel optimistic after initial conversations.

If the market stays near the “shorter years, high AAV” lane, the Mets profile as favorites. If a longer-term offer arrives from a rising contender like the Orioles, the negotiation turns into a test of New York’s appetite for term.

According to OMS Sports & other sources, the Orioles are making calls to Pete Alonso and Kyle Tucker. Many expect Baltimore to be an underdog for a top FA. #birdland pic.twitter.com/ZHFdsrVMyc
— Orioles magic (@OriolesMagic23) November 11, 2025